Lab 13: Orbits


Credit/Permission: For text, © David Jeffery. For figures etc., as specified with the figure etc. / Only for reading and use by the instructors and students of the UNLV astronomy laboratory course.

This is a lab exercise with observations. The observations can be dropped if necessary since the lab exercise can be made sufficiently challinging without them. For the observations, see Sky map: Las Vegas: current time and weather.

Sections

  1. Objectives (AKA Purpose)
  2. Preparation
  3. Tasks and Criteria for Success
  4. Task Master
  5. Determination of Orbital Periods
  6. Determination of the Mean Orbital Radii
  7. Determination of the Astronomical Unit
  8. Naked-Eye/Telescopic Observations
  9. Finale
  10. Post Mortem
  11. Lab Exercise
  12. Report Form: RMI Qualification: If you do NOT have a printer or do NOT want to waste paper, you will have to hand print the Report Form in sufficient detail for your own use.
  13. General Instructor Prep
  14. Instructor Notes: Access to lab instructors only.
  15. Lab Key: Access to lab instructors only.
  16. Prep Task:
  17. Quiz Preparation: General Instructions
  18. Prep Quizzes and Prep Quiz Keys
  19. Quiz Keys: Access to lab instructors only.


  1. Objectives (AKA Purpose)

  2. The main objective is to learn something about orbits, primarily of planets including exoplanets.

    We touch on the following topics:

    1. Planet apparent motions on the sky. Remember, in astronomy "apparent" does NOT mean illusionary: "apparent" means as seen from the Earth.
    2. Planet physical motions: i.e., their motions relative to the local inertial frame (which is well approximated for the Solar System by the reference frame of the fixed stars).
    3. Weather permitting, we make observations with the naked eye and/or telescope of the astronomical objects currently available in the sky.


  3. Preparation

  4. Do the preparation required by your lab instructor.


    1. Prep Items:

      1. Read this lab exercise itself: Lab 13: Orbits.

        Some of the Tasks can be completed ahead of the lab period. Doing some of them ahead of lab period would be helpful.

      2. It is probably best to print out a copy of Report Form on the lab room printer when you get to the lab room since updates to the report forms are ongoing.

        However, you can print a copy ahead of time if you like especially if want to do some parts ahead of time. You might have to compensate for updates in this case.

        The Lab Exercise itself is NOT printed in the lab ever. That would be killing forests and the Lab Exercise is designed to be an active web document.

      3. Do the prep for quiz (if there is one) suggested by your instructor.

        General remarks about quiz prep are given at Quiz Preparation: General Instructions.

        For DavidJ's lab sections, the quiz prep is doing all the items listed here and self-testing with the Prep Quizzes and Prep Quiz Keys if they exist.

      4. This is an observing lab. So you should review Telescope Operation and List of Tricks for the Telescope as needed.

        Review the parts of the Celestron C8 telescope in the figure below (local link / general link: telescope_c8_diagram.html).

        You should also review the Observation Safety Rules.


      5. There are are many keywords that you need to know for this lab. Many of these you will learn sufficiently well by reading over the Lab Exercise itself.

        However to complement and/or supplement the reading, you should at least read the intro of a sample of the articles linked to the following keywords etc. so that you can define and/or understand some keywords etc. at the level of our class.

        A further list of keywords which you are NOT required to look at---but it would be useful to do so---is:

          Hm.

    2. Prep Items for Instructors:

      1. From the General Instructor Prep, review as needed:
        1. Basic Prep.
        2. Usual Startup Procedure.
        3. Usual Shutdown Procedure.

      2. You need to put out rulers and protractors.

      3. This is an observational lab. However, the observations are only a small part and can be omitted if the seeing is bad.

        The sky alignment on the telescopes may NOT needed if the students are only going to make quick sketches.

        However, if you are going to larger telescope magnification than provided by the 40-mm eyepieces, sky alignment is probably a good idea.

      4. The lab exercise is intended eventually to be a complete lesson on orbits and extention of Lab 5: Planets.


  5. Task Master

    1. Task Master:

        EOF

      1. Task 1: A Touch of Pure Algebra. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      2. Task 2: Planet Motion During a Synodic Period. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      3. Task 3: Orbital Period Formulae. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      4. Task 4: Orbital Period Calculation. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      5. Task 5: The Mean Orbital Radius of an Inferior Planet.
      6. Task 6: The Mean Orbital Radius of a Superior Planet. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      7. Task 7: Simple Astronomical Unit Questions. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      8. Task 8: The Determination of the Astronomical Unit. Optional at the discretion of the instructor.
      9. Task 9: Naked-Eye/Telescopic Observations

      End of Task


  6. Determination of Orbital Periods

  7. In this section, we determine approximate orbital periods of the planets.

    We are following in crude way the footsteps of Nicolaus Copernicus (1473--1543).

    1. Assumptions:

      We assume the heliocentric solar system model, of course.

      But we will simplify our work by assuming (a) circular orbits centered on the Sun, (b) the circular orbits are aligned with the ecliptic plane and (c) constant revolution rates for the planets.

      We also assume the planets revolve counterclockwise (a direction we also call eastward) as viewed from the north celestial pole (NCP)---our Space Ghost view of the Solar System.

      We also neglect the distinction between solar orbital periods and sidereal orbital periods---for the Earth, this is the difference between the solar year and sidereal year.

    2. Direct Observables and the Synodic Period:

      The Earth's orbital period---the year---is a direct observable with heliocentric solar system model.


      It is just the time it takes the
      Sun to move once around the ecliptic from a geocentric point of view.

      But the other planet orbital periods are NOT direct observables.

      The direct observable for the planet is the synodic period.

      The synodic period is the time it takes for a planet to return to the same angular position relative to the Sun.

      To give a concrete picture, the synodic period is the time between, e.g.,

      1. Greatest eastern elongations for an inferior planet
      2. Oppositions for a superior planets.

    3. Task 1: A Touch of Pure Algebra:

      Now for the a touch of pure algebra.

      Sub Tasks:

      1. Given 0 =1/a + 1/b + 1/c, solve for a in terms of b and c.

        Answer:

        
        
        
        
        
            

      2. Show that your solution can be written a = -b/(1+b/c).

        Answer:

        
        
        
        
            

      3. Now, mutatis mutandis, solve for b and c. HINT: Proof by symmetry and cycling the variables suffices.

        Answer:

      End of Task

    4. Synodic Period to Orbital Period:

      Say you have 2 planets: planet 1 and planet 2

      Say they are aligned at time zero.

      The next time they are aligned is 1 synodic period later.

      During that 1 synodic period one planet has lapped the other one.

      1. Task 2: Planet Motion During a Synodic Period:

        Draw a diagram illustrating inner planet 1 lapping outer planet 2 during 1 synodic period.

        End of Task

      2. Task 3: Orbital Period Formulae:

        The relative difference in angle after 1 synodic period is ±360, where the upper case if for leading planet and the lower for the trailing planet.

        Thus,

          ±360 = R_1*t - R_2*t  ,
        
                 where R_1 is the angular velocity of planet 1,
                       R_2 is the angular velocity of planet 2,
                       and t is the synodic period.  
        Sub Tasks:

        1. Now R_1=360/t_1 and R_2=360/t_2.

          Show that 1/(±t) = 1/t_1-1/t_2 .

          Answer:

        2. Now making use of the algebra you did above in Task 1: A Touch of Pure Algebra: Sub Task 2, derive the orbital period formulae:
                     t_2                     t_1
            t_1 = -----------  and  t_2 = -----------   .
                  1+t_2/(±t)              1-t_1/(±t) 

          Answer:

        End of Task

    5. Task 4: Orbital Period Calculation:

      Using the orbital period formulae derived just above in Task 3: Orbital Period Formulae, complete the following table by filling in the 2 blanks.

           _________________________________________________________________________
      
           Table:  Planet Orbital Periods and Synodic Periods in Julian years (Jyr)
           _________________________________________________________________________
      
             Planet           Orbital Period         Synodic Period
                             (sidereal years)       (sidereal years)
           _________________________________________________________________________
      
             Mercury            0.240846                 0.317
             Venus              ________                 1.599    
             Earth                  1                      -
             Mars               ________                 2.135    
             Jupiter             11.86                   1.092
             Saturn              29.46                   1.035
             Uranus              84.01                   1.012
             Neptune            164.8                    1.004
             Pluto (ex-planet)  248.1                    1.002
           _________________________________________________________________________
      Answer:

      End of Task


  8. Determination of the Mean Orbital Radii

  9. In this section, we determine approximate mean orbital radii of the planets.

    We are following again in crude way the footsteps of Nicolaus Copernicus (1473--1543).

    We make the same assumptions as in the section Determination of Orbital Periods: see Assumptions.

    1. Planetary Configurations Redux:

      Planetary configurations are NOT just observational curiosities---which were probably used in astrology---but I don't know.

      The are/were useful in determining the orbital parameters.

      We've already used planetary configurations as a mental aid in determining orbital periods

      Just have a look again at the common planetary configurations in the figure below (local link / general link: planetary_configurations.html).


    2. Task 5: The Mean Orbital Radius of an Inferior Planet:

      Sub Tasks:

      1. Take a good look at the greatest eastern elongation of an inferior planet in the planetary configuration figure above (local link / general link: planetary_configurations.html). Have you done this?     Y / N    
      2. What is the closed geometric shape marked out by the inferior planet, the Sun, and the Earth? Be as specific as possible. HINT: At greatest eastern elongation, the Earth-planet line is tangent to a circle.     ___________________    
      3. Let the Earth-Sun distance be A, the Sun-planet distance be R, the Earth-planet distance be D, and the angle at the Earth vertex be θ. Recalling the sine function of trigonometry, we have R/A=sin(θ). Solve for R.     ___________________    
      4. What is the name of distance A in astro jargon?     ___________________    
      5. Is θ a direct observable?     Y / N    
      6. So can R be determined by simple measurements?     Y / N    
      7. Could Copernicus have obtained the distance to the inferior planets in astronomical units (AUs) using the method just explicated above?     ___________________    
      8. Can the orbital radius R for superior planets be found by the method just explicated above? Explain. HINT: What planetary configuration corresponds to a greatest elongation for a superior planet?

        Answer: ! Answer space is in the Report Form, NOT in the lab itself. >

      End of Task

    3. Task 6: The Mean Orbital Radius of a Superior Planet:

      Sub Tasks:

      1. Take a good look at the easstern quadrature of a superior planet in the planetary configuration figure above (local link / general link: planetary_configurations.html). Have you done this?     Y / N    
      2. What is the closed geometric shape marked out by the superior planet, the Sun, and the Earth? Be as specific as possible. HINT: At quadrature the Earth-planet line is tangent to a circle.     ___________________    
      3. Let the Earth-Sun distance be A, the Sun-planet distance be R, the Earth-planet distance be D, and the angle at the Sun vertex be φ. Recalling the cosine function of trigonometry, we have A/R=cos(φ). Solve for R.     ___________________    
      4. What is distance A in astro jargon?     ___________________    
      5. Is φ a direct observable.     ___________________    
      6. So can R in astronomical units be determined by one simple observation?     Y / N    
      7. Draw a diagram below showing the superior planet at opposition and a time t later when the superior planet is at eastern quadrature. Note that both Earth and superior planet move during time t. Label φ on this diagram.

      8. What the angular velocity ω of the Earth RELATIVE to the superior planet as seen from the Sun given that the superior planet's synodic period t_syn (which is among other things the time period between oppositions). HINT: Remember, there are 360° in a circle.     ___________________    
      9. Now solve for R in terms of A, ω and t.     ___________________    
      10. Could Copernicus have determined the mean orbital radii of the superior planets in terms of astronomical units given data available to him? Explain.

        Answer:

      End of Task


  10. Determination of the Astronomical Unit

  11. The astronomical unit (AU) is the natural unit for distances in Solar System and, since the Solar System is our reference planetary system, it is the natural unit for other planetary systems too.

    Addtionally, the astronomical unit is the baseline for parallax measurements to extrasolar astro-bodies as illustrated in the figure below (local link / general link: parallax_stellar.html).


    But to use
    Solar System distances and other distances given in astronomical units for physical understanding, we need to know the astronomical unit in terms of the standard distance units which in modern times are distance units used in the metric system.

    We consider determinations of the astronomical unit in the following subsections:

    1. Pre-Modern Astronomical Unit Determinations:

      The ancient Greek astronomers came up with range of values some of which were order-of-magnitude correct and others wildly wrong. Clearly, they did NOT really have a conclusive method of determination.

      In the 17th century, determinations accurate to 10 % were achieved. Since the 1970s, determinations accurate to 9 significant figures has been achieved (see Wikipedia: Astronomical unit: History)

    2. Modern Astronomical Unit Determinations:

      Modern accuracy in determination of the astronomical unit is achieved by direct radar measurements. One measures, the travel time for a radar pulse to return from an inner Solar System planet, divides that time by 2, and multiplies by the vacuum light speed to get the distance to the planet in meters.

      The distance to the planet is accurately known by astrometry in astronomical units. Using the distance accurately in both meters and astronomical units, the astronomical unit in meters can be found.

    3. The Exact Modern Astronomical Unit:

      Historically, the astronomical unit was defined as Earth-Sun---which in turn is the sum of the aphelion and perihelion center-to-center distances divided by 2.

      However, in there are actually many finicky small effects that have to be accounted for in order to make exact determinations using the historical definitions. These effects had to be included in the definition making it rather complex and always making the determination of the astronomical unit subject to change.

      In 2012, International Astronomical Union (IAU) decided to simply define the astronomical unit as 1.49597870700*10**11 m exactly (see Wikipedia: Astronomical unit: Development of unit definition).

      This modern definition gives a value very, very close to the historical definition determinations and is fixed for good. No need to change all the distances given in astronomical units when the determination of the astronomical unit changed a smidgen.

      Note:

        1 parsec = 3.08567758*10*16 meters
                 = 3.26379772 ... light-years
                 = 206264.806 ... astronomical units
      
        1 light-year = 9.454254955*10**15 meters
                     = 0.3063915365687 ... parsecs
                     = 63197.7909 ... astronomical units 
    4. Understanding the Solar System with the Astronomical Unit:

      Because the astronomical unit (AU) is the natural unit for the Solar System, it is easy to comprehend Solar System distances in astronomical units.

      This point is illustrated in the figure below (local link / general link: solar_system_inner.html).


    5. Task 7: Simple Astronomical Unit Questions:

      Sub Tasks:

      1. Why does one divide the radar travel time by 2 to get the distance to a planet?

        Answer:

      2. What is the formula for the astronomical unit in terms the planet in x meters (x * 1 meter) and the planet distance in y astronomical units (y * 1 AU)? HINT: Equate x * 1 meter and y * 1 AU and solve for 1 AU.

        Answer:

      3. What is the conversion factor for converting a distance in astronomical units to one in meters? HINT: Any number can be multiplied by 1 and 1 = A/B where A and B are the same quantity in different units.

        Answer:

      End of Task

    6. Task 8: The Determination of the Astronomical Unit:

      Sub Tasks:

      1. Consider your printed diagram of the inner Solar System from section Elongations and Planetary Configurations Today.

        Draw a triangle with vertices at Earth, the Sun and Venus.

        We neglect the slight eccentricity of the Earth's orbit, and just take the Earth-Sun distance on the diagram to be the astronomical unit.

        Measure 2 angles and determine the Earth-Venus distance in astronomical units using the law of sines.

          The law of sines is given and proven in subsection just below.

        The angles and the Earth-Venus in astronomical units are:



      2. Now we need the Earth-Venus distance in meters for today's date:

        Click on Earth-to-Venus to get that distance approximately in light-minutes. The value is: _____________________

        Convert the distance in light-minutes to meters. The value is: _____________________

        Work space:

      3. Now give your determination of the astronomical unit in meters: _____________________

        Work space:

      4. What is the relative difference as a percentage of your determination of the astronomical unit from the exact modern astronomical unit 1.49597870700*10**11 m?

        Work space:

      End of Task

    7. The Law of Sines:

      In order to make our own determination of the astronomical units from the diagram of the inner Solar System generated by TheSky, we need the law of sines.

      The law of sines is given and proven in the figure below (local link / general link: law_of_sines.html).



  12. Naked-Eye//Telescopic Observations

    1. Task 9: Naked-Eye/Telescopic Observations:

      For RMI, the General Task: Naked-Eye Observations can only be done with naked-eye observations, unless the RMI student happens to have access to telescope in which case the naked-eye observations can be supplemented by telescopic observations if the RMI student so wishes.

      For IPI, the instructor should set up C8 telescopes for opportunistic telescopic observations in lieu of naked-eye observations, weather permitting.

      EOF

      End of Task


  13. Finale

  14. Goodnight all.



  15. Post Mortem

  16. Post mortem comments that may often apply specifically to Lab 13: Orbits:

    1. Nothing yet.