Frames of reference

    Image 1 Caption: A cartoon illustrating the nested hierarchy of celestial frames (called center-of-mass inertial frames in the cartoon) in the observable universe and an astrophysical rotating frame (attached to, e.g., a moon, planet or star). In our discussion below, we do NOT consider rotating frames. For those, see the Mechanics files: frame_rotating.html and frame_inertial_free_fall.html.

    In this figure, we explicate celestial frames and their largest special case comoving frames which are NOT illustrated in the cartoon in Image 1, but of which there is an example in Image 2 below.

    Features:

    1. A celestial frame is just a center-of-mass (CM) inertial frames used to analyze systems of astro-bodies. Usually the only ordinary EXTERNAL and INTERNAL force is gravity. Inertial forces sometimes arise, but its beyond our scope to go into that detail.

      Note celestial frame is often used as a natural synonym for the system of astro-bodies it is used to analyze.

    2. The EXTERNAL gravitational field determines the center of mass of the system and tidal forces.

    3. Usually, celestial frames are chosen to be gravitationally-bound systems simply because those are ones that tell you most about how the astrophysical realm works. And you can usually analyze a celestial frame with only limited knowledge about its environoment, which it why it is convenient to use them in analysis.

    4. There is a whole nested hierarchy of useful celestial frames all of which are gravitationally-bound systems, except comoving frames. Many celestial frames of one level are nested in one celestial frame of the next level. The center of mass motion of any celestial frame is analyzed in the celestial frame of the next level it is nested in.

      The hierarchy is illustrated in Image 1 and is specified (NOT exhaustively) as follows:

      1. planet-moon systems: e.g., the Earth-Moon system.
      2. planetary systems: e.g., the Solar System.
      3. star clusters: Note many planetary systems are NOT in star clusters: e.g., the Solar System.
      4. galaxies: e.g., Milky Way.
      5. galaxy clusters (e.g., the Virgo Cluster) and galaxy groups (e.g., the Local Group (of Galaxies)). Note a galaxy NOT in a galaxy cluster or galaxy group is a field galaxy.
      6. A comoving frame is any spherical region in space large enough to obey the cosmological principle: i.e., its size-scaleless properties (e.g., density, distribution of galaxy types, expansion of the universe behavior) are close to the average of the whole observable universe. The center of mass of the spherical region is its geometrical center since the spherical region is assumed to have nearly UNIFORM density How large does the spherical region have to be? Current thinking is that its size scale has to be ⪆ 370 megaparsecs Mpc (∼ 1000 Mly = 1 Gly) (Wikipedia: Violations of homogeneity; Swala et al. 2025). This size scale can be called the Yadav scale after the lead author of the paper which specified it.

      local universe to 150 Mpc

    5. Image 2 Caption: A map of the large-scale structure of the universe of the local universe out to ∼ 300 Mpc = 0.30 Gpc (∼ 2 % of the observable universe radius = 14.3 Gpc) from the center at the unlabeled Milky Way: i.e., to cosmological redshift z ≅ 0.07 and lookback time ≅ 1 Gyr.

      The Laniakea Supercluster is marked in yellow in Image 2.

    6. The spherical region in Image 2 is our comoving frame: i.e., the comoving frame centered on us: "us" being any of the Solar System, the Milky Way, and the Local Group. It is of order the Yadav scale: i.e., ⪆ 300 Mpc.

    7. Using measurement of the cosmic microwave background (CMB, T = 2.72548(57) K (Fixsen 2009)), we can, in fact, determine our peculiar velocities relative to the center of mass of our comoving frame (which is where we are in our comoving frame). The center of mass itself just participates in the mean expansion of the universe.

      Our peculiar velocities:

      1. The Solar System center of mass (i.e., center of mass of the Solar System) is moving at 368(2) km/s in some direction (see Wikipedia: CMB dipole anisotropy (ℓ=1); Caltech: Description of CMB Anisotropies).

      2. The Milky Way center of mass is moving at 552(6) km/s in the direction 10.5 hours right ascension (RA), 0.24° declination (Dec or δ) in equatorial coordinates (epoch J2000) which is toward near the center of constellation Hydra (see Wikipedia: Milky Way: Velocity).

      3. Local Group of Galaxies center of mass is moving at 627(22) km/s in some direction (see Wikipedia: CMB dipole anisotropy (ℓ=1); Caltech: Description of CMB Anisotropies).

    8. Galaxy superclusters (e.g., those seen in Image 2) are NOT gravitationally bound systems in general. This means they will be pulled apart eventually by the expansion of the universe. Galaxy superclusters are generally NOT analyzed using celestial frames, but in computer simulations of structure formation (AKA large-scale structure formation).

    EOF

    Images:
    1. Credit/Permission: © David Jeffery, 2021 / Own work.
      Image link: Itself.
    2. Credit/Permission: © Richard Powell 2016 (uploaded to Wikipedia by User:AdAstraPerScientiam, 2009) / Creative Commons CC BY-SA 2.5.
      Image link: Wikimedia Commons: File:Laniakea.gif.
    3. Credit/Permission: © David Jeffery, 2004 / Own work.
      Image link: Itself.
    Local file: local link: frame_hierarchy_astro.html.
    Extended file:
    Mechanics file: frame_hierarchy_astro_4.html.
    File:
    Mechanics file: frame_hierarchy_astro.html.