evolutionary sequence in the growth of massive elliptical

    Caption: "This graphic shows the evolutionary sequence in the growth of massive elliptical galaxy (e.g., cD or giant elliptical galaxies) over 13 Gyr, as gleaned from space-based and ground-based telescopic observations. The growth of this class of galaxies is quickly driven by rapid star formation and galaxy mergers." (Slightly edited.)

    The growth of massive ellipticals is called galactic cannibalism---they eat their own.

    Actually, galaxy formation and evolution is NOT yet perfectly understood. In particular, the galaxy quenching (i.e., the turning off of star formation) is NOT well understood.

    Some considerations on galaxy quenching:

    1. Galaxy mergers and feedback from inflow to central supermassive black holes are important ingredients.

    2. Galaxy mergers randomize orbits of stars and interstellar medium (ISM) and eject some of them/it into intergalactic space.

    3. So galaxy mergers should create ellipticals.

      Certainly, in the early early formation of large-scale structure circa 1 Gyr after the Big Bang, galaxy mergers also created spiral galaxies or galaxies that evolved to being spiral galaxies. But this process may have turned off or drastically slowed over cosmic time since then.

    4. Why do ellipticals NOT evolve back into being spiral galaxies or at least have much star formation in the modern observable universe?

      Electromagnetic radiation (EMR) from accretion disks from sufficiently large central supermassive black holes is thought to keep any ISM gas too hot and buoyant to cool, lose pressure support, and initiate star formation.

      We now know that there is hot ISM gas in ellipticals. It just tends to rather invisible radiating in the X-ray band????.

      There is, however, little interstellar dust in ellipticals. Without new star formation, interstellar dust is NOT much replenished since it is made from metals created and ejected from stars in strong stellar winds or when they go and supernova.

      If a galaxy merger strips most interstellar dust and thereby stops star formation by removing the cooling and shielding effect of the interstellar dust, it may NOT be possible to replenish the interstellar dust sufficiently in the modern observable universe to restart star formation.

    5. Another factor is that the modern observable universe just has a lower density of intergalactic medium (IGM) (made of mainly of hydrogen and helium gas) compared to the epoch of early formation of large-scale structure (circa 1 Gyr after the Big Bang) just due to the expansion of the universe. Cosmic time circa 1 Gyr after the Big Bang corresponds to cosmological redshift z ≅ 5.5 (see Cosmology file: cosmos_distance_z_10000.html; Chip Kobulnicky: Cosmology Calculator; Chip Kobulnicky: Cosmology Calculator: z∈[5.5,6.4]). Since then the cosmic scale factor has increased by a factor of z+1 ≅ 6.5 which has caused density of the IGM to decrease on average in density by factor of order 270. The decrease in IGM must have a strong tendency to reduce inflow to galaxies causing star formation to be generally reduced. In fact, star formation in the observable universe seems to have peaked at cosmic time ∼ 4 Gyr. This peak epoch is called cosmic noon (z≅2, cosmic time ∼ 4 Gyr; lookback time ∼ 10 Gyr).

    6. In fact, as just discussed, there are several factors turning off star formation in elliptical galaxies and other galaxies too and the exact weighting of them is NOT fully answered question. The study of galaxy quenching is still in its early days.

    7. For a more extended discussion of galaxy quenching, see Galaxies file: galaxy_quenching.html.

    Credit/Permission: NASA/ESO/Sune Toft (Niels Bohr Institute) 2014 (uploaded to Wikipedia by User:Jmencisom, 2014) / Public domain.
    Image link: Wikipedia: File:Development of massive elliptical galaxies.jpg.
    Local file: local link: galaxy_elliptical_evolution.html.
    File: Galaxies file: galaxy_elliptical_evolution.html.